Kai Quan has correctly organized his essay and has clearly stated his ideas. He has stated his thesis by writing that nuclear power plants have some potential threats that outweight the benefits we can get. As an opposition, he gives some strong points that nuclear power plants should not be developed further. He also rebuts the idea that Generation IV nuclear reactors allow waste recycling, and instead he writes that recycling nuclear's waste can be dangerous if the plutonium produced after recycling is misused.
Nevertheless, there are still some grammatical errors in the essay. In line 26, for example, he wrote "...which can be used as it can be used as a fuel also.". I think this is simply a typo-error. He should wrote "...which can be used as a fuel also".
Another grammatical error occurs in line 43, "...which are greener to the environment and not as adverse, funding should be used to improve the efficiency...". I think it lacks a connector. It should be better if he wrote "...which are greener to the environment and not as adverse, and funding should be used to improve the efficiency...".
The last error I find is in line 44, "...able to suppress the fears of citizens on building nuclear power plants as well as contributing in fighting against climate changes.". This is the problem on parallelism. It should be "...able to suppress the fears of citizens on building nuclear power plants as well as contribute in fighting against climate changes." In other words, "contributing" should be changed to "contribute" as it has to be the same kind as "suppress".
Overall, I think his essay is good enough. He has done a good job from expressing his ideas, organizing the essay, and choosing a suitable choice words.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
The reviewer had done a decent peer review on my writing assignment two and pointed the grammatical errors that I had made while writing the assignment. Even though there are a lot of grammatical errors, they are similar as he had written it in present tense. On this note, the reviewer should write the review in past tense form.
ReplyDeleteSome of the grammatical errors that I have identified (apart from the tense errors) are below.
1. “I think this is simply a typo-eror. He should wrote..” The correct sentence would be to change ‘wrote’ to ‘write’ instead.
2. “He has done a good job from expressing…” It should be “He has done a good job in expressing…”
3. “… and choosing a suitable choice words” In this statement, it can be editted by removing the ‘a’.
Grammatical errors aside, the reviewer could have given more focus on whether the arguments and rebuttals in the essay are well supported or not. It will definitely be much appreciated if the reviewer also address the structure and organization issues more in depth.