Sunday, March 28, 2010
Blog 5: Peer review on Moses' WA2
Moses’ essay has shown several advantages of nuclear power which can be achieved in the future by overcoming the technological difficulties. However, the potential of getting success is still in the paper plan. Although the scientists and engineers can promise many benefits of using generation IV reactors, the public’s fears still exist. Since, everyone has already observed the disaster caused by nuclear radiation or nuclear explosion. Moreover, the deep understanding about nuclear technology only belongs to a minor population such as nuclear scientists and engineers. Therefore, in order to make people feel secure about the nuclear technology is not an easy issue. The effect of radiation on human body such as cancer is the thing that cannot be visualized by eyes and discovered in a short term period. Nobody prefers to stay with the thing that is dangerous not only to his health but also his life. Furthermore, terrorism is another obvious issue that can happen during the transportation of nuclear materials. If we can develop a high technology, terrorists can achieve it also.
And i disagree that nuclear reactor does not release carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. Many studies have confirmed that the amount of carbon emission from nuclear energy is not less than the equivalent amount of carbon emission from wind, hydro and bio energy. Hence, there is no reason for us to support and develop a technology which has much dangerous potential and is not clean at all. Instead of that, focus on other green and natural energy is definitely a brilliant decision.
Friday, March 26, 2010
Peer review of Adrian's essay
Adrian’s essay was well organized and but there is something that I don’t agree with him. Adrian supported his thesis from three aspects: safety, cost and waste.
Firstly, let’s talk about safety. The danger of nuclear power plant comes not only from terrorism but also from operation and system danger from the nuclear plant itself. In the first paragraph, Adrian claimed that the new generation reactor, VHTR, has “passive safety”. I do not really understand the meaning of this phase. But I know that he was saying that VHTR has highly safety. Can it be 100 percent safe? Of course not. Then think about what happened in Chernobyl. The whole Ukraine and most part of Europe were affected form one single accident. The damage level of nuclear power is simply too vast to bear. Nobody can guarantee this will never happen again. In paragraph 2, Adrian talked about terrorism. Again, nobody can say terrorists will never be able to blow up one reactor.
Secondly, it comes to cost. In paragraph 3, Adrian mentioned that “capital investment is very low”. But we know from Nuclear power’s new dawn that it takes 1 billion to just build one reactor. Obviously, one reactor is not enough for many countries to satisfy its power demand. Adrian also mentioned “low operating and maintenance cost”. But when some poor developing countries cannot build one at the very beginning, it makes no sense to take about operation and maintenance cost. Besides, the cost of nuclear power is 14 cents per kWh, which is much higher than that of solar energy (5 to 10 cents).
At last, waste is also one of Adrian’s grounds of argument. In paragraph 4, Adrian argued that “the waste can be developed to reduce the half-lives of the radiation.” But the “half lives” can still last for thousands of years. How can we ensure that they will still stay away from people thousands of years later? There is no way to do that.
So, the three grounds of argument that Adrian used to support his thesis failed. Thus, his thesis does not hold. We should not put money on nuclear power.
Wednesday, March 24, 2010
Blog 5
Reviewer: Han Lin
Chriswini has clearly state her stand in her thesis statement. Also, she has chosen the reactors that she is going to talk about in her essay. This allows the readers to know what she is arguing for and help them to understand her stand. Chriswini has also done a good job in presenting her arguments. She has uses the ‘point-by-point’ pattern to organize her essay. First, she states the opposition argument and rebuts it with her own counterargument. She has a good use of connectors which link her points up very well. For example, she uses In addition this kind of connectors to link up the different arguments. Uses however to link up her counterargument with the argument. Lastly, her conclusion is well written which summarise her points and leave an impact for the reader.
However, I feel that her second argument can be improved. Her second argument states that the cost to invest, research and maintain a nuclear reactor is very high. She argues it with her own counterargument that the VHTR is more efficient and can produce more electricity. However, I feel that she can improve her rebuttal by stating that cost for investment, research and maintenance of non-nuclear reactors are also expensive and elaborate on this point. This will make her counterargument appears to be stronger. The last sentence, I think ‘neglect’ seems to be a wrong choice of word selection.
As for her grammar mistakes, here are some which I have identified:
• Firstly, opponents of nuclear energy argue that with the development of nuclear power, the nuclear power plants will be prone to terrorist activity. will be proned
• VHTR are pebbled-bed reactors with each pebble itself is a mini-nuclear-reactor. is
• Therefore, we should not neglect on exploring more on the VHTR concept, as it is beneficial to society. No need for the on
Overall, I think Chriswini has done a great job in writing her essay.
Tuesday, March 23, 2010
Blog 5 : Peer Review of Kai Quan's Writing Assignment 2
Nevertheless, there are still some grammatical errors in the essay. In line 26, for example, he wrote "...which can be used as it can be used as a fuel also.". I think this is simply a typo-error. He should wrote "...which can be used as a fuel also".
Another grammatical error occurs in line 43, "...which are greener to the environment and not as adverse, funding should be used to improve the efficiency...". I think it lacks a connector. It should be better if he wrote "...which are greener to the environment and not as adverse, and funding should be used to improve the efficiency...".
The last error I find is in line 44, "...able to suppress the fears of citizens on building nuclear power plants as well as contributing in fighting against climate changes.". This is the problem on parallelism. It should be "...able to suppress the fears of citizens on building nuclear power plants as well as contribute in fighting against climate changes." In other words, "contributing" should be changed to "contribute" as it has to be the same kind as "suppress".
Overall, I think his essay is good enough. He has done a good job from expressing his ideas, organizing the essay, and choosing a suitable choice words.