Writer : Chriswini
Reviewer: Han Lin
Chriswini has clearly state her stand in her thesis statement. Also, she has chosen the reactors that she is going to talk about in her essay. This allows the readers to know what she is arguing for and help them to understand her stand. Chriswini has also done a good job in presenting her arguments. She has uses the ‘point-by-point’ pattern to organize her essay. First, she states the opposition argument and rebuts it with her own counterargument. She has a good use of connectors which link her points up very well. For example, she uses In addition this kind of connectors to link up the different arguments. Uses however to link up her counterargument with the argument. Lastly, her conclusion is well written which summarise her points and leave an impact for the reader.
However, I feel that her second argument can be improved. Her second argument states that the cost to invest, research and maintain a nuclear reactor is very high. She argues it with her own counterargument that the VHTR is more efficient and can produce more electricity. However, I feel that she can improve her rebuttal by stating that cost for investment, research and maintenance of non-nuclear reactors are also expensive and elaborate on this point. This will make her counterargument appears to be stronger. The last sentence, I think ‘neglect’ seems to be a wrong choice of word selection.
As for her grammar mistakes, here are some which I have identified:
• Firstly, opponents of nuclear energy argue that with the development of nuclear power, the nuclear power plants will be prone to terrorist activity. will be proned
• VHTR are pebbled-bed reactors with each pebble itself is a mini-nuclear-reactor. is
• Therefore, we should not neglect on exploring more on the VHTR concept, as it is beneficial to society. No need for the on
Overall, I think Chriswini has done a great job in writing her essay.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Thank you for your compliments. Thank you for pointing out that the second argument can be improved by giving more elaboration to strengthen the point.
ReplyDeleteI do not agree with your suggestion for the first grammatical error. “Will be prone” is already correct. Then for the second, I agree with you since I forget to change to singular verb to “is”.
The reviewer has made some grammatical errors:
•Wrong use of verb form
Mistake 1 : Chriswini has clearly state her stand in her thesis statement
Correction : Chriswini has clearly stated her stand in her thesis statement
Mistake 2 : She has uses the ‘point-by-point’ pattern to organize her essay.
Correction : She has used the ‘point-by-point’ pattern to organize her essay.
Mistake 3 : Lastly, her conclusion is well written which summarise her points and leave an impact for the reader.
Correction : Lastly, her conclusion is well written which summarises her points and leaves an impact for the reader.
•Wrong word order
Mistake 4 : She has a good use of connectors which link her points up very well.
Correction : She has used a good of connectors which link her points up very well.
•Wrong choice of word and preposition
Mistake 5 : For example, she uses In addition this kind of connectors to link up the different arguments.
Correction : For example, she uses “in addition” as a connector to link the different arguments.
•Incomplete sentence
Mistake 6 : Uses however to link up her counterargument with the argument.
Correction : She uses “however” to show her counterargument.
Chriswini Tanaka