Welcome to Our Blog!

Please take your time to read some academic essays that we have published!

Friday, March 26, 2010

Peer review of Adrian's essay

Adrian’s essay was well organized and but there is something that I don’t agree with him. Adrian supported his thesis from three aspects: safety, cost and waste.

Firstly, let’s talk about safety. The danger of nuclear power plant comes not only from terrorism but also from operation and system danger from the nuclear plant itself. In the first paragraph, Adrian claimed that the new generation reactor, VHTR, has “passive safety”. I do not really understand the meaning of this phase. But I know that he was saying that VHTR has highly safety. Can it be 100 percent safe? Of course not. Then think about what happened in Chernobyl. The whole Ukraine and most part of Europe were affected form one single accident. The damage level of nuclear power is simply too vast to bear. Nobody can guarantee this will never happen again. In paragraph 2, Adrian talked about terrorism. Again, nobody can say terrorists will never be able to blow up one reactor.

Secondly, it comes to cost. In paragraph 3, Adrian mentioned that “capital investment is very low”. But we know from Nuclear power’s new dawn that it takes 1 billion to just build one reactor. Obviously, one reactor is not enough for many countries to satisfy its power demand. Adrian also mentioned “low operating and maintenance cost”. But when some poor developing countries cannot build one at the very beginning, it makes no sense to take about operation and maintenance cost. Besides, the cost of nuclear power is 14 cents per kWh, which is much higher than that of solar energy (5 to 10 cents).

At last, waste is also one of Adrian’s grounds of argument. In paragraph 4, Adrian argued that “the waste can be developed to reduce the half-lives of the radiation.” But the “half lives” can still last for thousands of years. How can we ensure that they will still stay away from people thousands of years later? There is no way to do that.

So, the three grounds of argument that Adrian used to support his thesis failed. Thus, his thesis does not hold. We should not put money on nuclear power.

1 comment:

  1. I agree with some points the author has raised. But obviously the author stands in the point of the opponents view. His review seems having a debate with me on whether nuclear reactor should be further developed or not. As a supporter for nuclear reactor, of course I need only raise a few points from the opponents, rebut these points and focus more on my only points. I cannot raise all the opponents' point and elaborate them thoroughly. The author has failed to make a good review on my essay in three important aspects, contents,structure and language. In contrast, his review is more like a face-to-face debate with me on whether nuclear reactors should be further developed. He should focus more on my essay rather than critizing all my points with all his opposing points in mind.

    ReplyDelete