Welcome to Our Blog!

Please take your time to read some academic essays that we have published!
Showing posts with label By Andre Setiawan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label By Andre Setiawan. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 23, 2010

Blog 5 : Peer Review of Kai Quan's Writing Assignment 2

Kai Quan has correctly organized his essay and has clearly stated his ideas. He has stated his thesis by writing that nuclear power plants have some potential threats that outweight the benefits we can get. As an opposition, he gives some strong points that nuclear power plants should not be developed further. He also rebuts the idea that Generation IV nuclear reactors allow waste recycling, and instead he writes that recycling nuclear's waste can be dangerous if the plutonium produced after recycling is misused.
Nevertheless, there are still some grammatical errors in the essay. In line 26, for example, he wrote "...which can be used as it can be used as a fuel also.". I think this is simply a typo-error. He should wrote "...which can be used as a fuel also".
Another grammatical error occurs in line 43, "...which are greener to the environment and not as adverse, funding should be used to improve the efficiency...". I think it lacks a connector. It should be better if he wrote "...which are greener to the environment and not as adverse, and funding should be used to improve the efficiency...".
The last error I find is in line 44, "...able to suppress the fears of citizens on building nuclear power plants as well as contributing in fighting against climate changes.". This is the problem on parallelism. It should be "...able to suppress the fears of citizens on building nuclear power plants as well as contribute in fighting against climate changes." In other words, "contributing" should be changed to "contribute" as it has to be the same kind as "suppress".
Overall, I think his essay is good enough. He has done a good job from expressing his ideas, organizing the essay, and choosing a suitable choice words.

Wednesday, February 24, 2010

Writing Assignment 1

Climate change treaties require cooperation from both developing and developed countries. Lack of such cooperation will not bring about a strong agreement, just like what happened in the recent Copenhagen Agreement. Learning from experience, developing and developed countries should try not to make the same mistake in the upcoming Mexico City event. In order to make succesful agreement, there are some things to be considered by both developing and developed countries. Finance, technology, manufacture, law, and socialization are especially important to take into account.

Finance, without a doubt, can be considered as the main problem faced by developing countries. Unlike developed countries, developing countries do not have such strong finance to handle climate change issues ("Climate of compromise", 2009). This causes developing countries tend to be averse toward climate change agreement. In this case, the cooperation from developed countries is important. Developed countries, which are stronger in terms of finance, should help developing countries by giving some budget money. In addition, developing and developed countries need to watch the flow of the budget and report every move made to the UNFCCC to prevent any corruption possibilities and to increase the efficiency use of the budget ("Climate of compromise", 2009).

Similar to finance, developing countries also need help in term of eco-friendly technology ("Climate of compromise", 2009). Developing countries do not have necessary knowledge to improve their own clean technologies, as opposite of developed countries. Once again, developed countries should be willing to give technological help to developing countries.

Meanwhile, manufacture should be essentially the main factor that needs to be considered by developed countries. Their vast manufacturing could be as well the main cause of greenhouse gas emission, just like China as the leader of carbon emission ("Climate of compromise", 2009) and United States. As a result, developed countries may want to reduce their manufactures and start to focus on tackling climate change issues. If that seems difficult, developed countries should at least use eco-friendly technology in their manufacturing processes.

Despite the difference between developing and developed countries, both of them should make use of their own laws in handling climate change problems. And, if necessary, they may want to make important amandments in their current laws to focus it more on climate change. For instance, giving standard of carbon gas emission to manufacturers, banning the use of hazardous materials to capture fishes, and punishing any littering actions.

Last but not least, socialization plays an important role for both developing and developed countries. It is better if we can socialize how important climate change issues are, hoping that more and more people will realize their roles to help the issues. For example, developing countries with more natural resources should socialize the important role of forests and other natural ecosystems in reducing carbon emission, just like what has been stated by Turner, Oppenheimer, and Wilcove (2009). And developed countries may socialize their people to change their life habits. For instance, being a vegetarian, or recycling used plastics and cans.

To sum up, there are several things that need to be done before we can make a strong and ratifiable agreement. Indeed, developing and developed countries may face different problems. But as long as there are a strong cooperation between them, and if they realize that they have to put a stop to climate change as soon as possible, a strong and ratifiable agreement will certainly be done. In addition, it is even possible to make all countries sign the agreement.

Reference

Climate of compromise (2009, October 22). Nature, p.1027-1028.

Turner, Will R., Oppenheimer, Michael, & Wilcove, David S. (2009). A force to fight global warming. Nature, p.278-279.

Wednesday, February 10, 2010

Peer Review of Han Lin's Summary

Han Lin has covered most of the ideas in the passage in his summary. He succesfully made a summary which is easy to understand. However, there are still some similar phrases with the passage itself, like "a major gap" (line 12-13) and "towards a low-carbon future" (line 18). He could actually replace those phrases to be "a distance" and "to lower their carbon emissions". There is also a wrong use of word in his summary, like "economics" (line 17). The correct one should be "economies". There is also an error in terms of parallelism, that is "...a few articles which focus on the problems developing countries may face and contribute to the global emission." (line 10-12). Because the first argument, "the problems developing countries may face", is a noun phrase, the second argument should also be a noun phrase. It should be "their contribution to global emission". And finally, he did not include the passage's conclusion in his summary, which is how international negotiations can be similar to scientific research. Overall, his summary is already good enough, but it has some mistakes which should be avoided next time.

Sunday, February 7, 2010

Summary of Climate Change : Issues and Response by Benjamin Sovacool

Greenhouse gases can be considered as one of significant contributor to climate change. Such gases, like carbon dioxide, mainly emits from fossil fuels, deforestation, agriculture, and waste. Although some European countries like Germany and Hungary can actually reduce their carbon dioxide emissions since 1997, all other countries show an increasing amount of the gas emission, especially United States and China. Until now, they are the two top countries with highest emissions of carbon dioxide. In this kind of situation, we need to give our best to take actions to reduce greenhouse gases emission, either as institution or as individual. As institution, we can take various actions such as reducing fossil fuel subsidies, giving standards of carbon dioxide emission of vehicles, promoting bioorganic fertilizers, and regulating waste management. Even as individual, we can actually help save the earth from climate change. For instances, investing shares or choosing a career in clean energy companies, and altering our lifestyles to a environmentally friendly direction. While not everyone can achieve the previous one, we can at least do the latter one. We can alter our lifestyles in various aspects like eating habits, households, and technologies. Eating less meat, or even becoming a vegetarian, reducing food waste and packaging, minimizing the uses of electrical appliances, purchasing environmentally friendly devices, and last but not least, reusing and recycling practices, can make a significant reduce of emission of greenhouse gases, and subsequently, saving our earth from the impact of climate change.