Welcome to Our Blog!

Please take your time to read some academic essays that we have published!

Wednesday, February 10, 2010

Peer review of Kelvin’s Summary

Kelvin’s summary on Dr. Sovacool’s lecture is grammatically smooth with seldom logical conflicts. Kelvin summarized many main points that Dr. Sovacool told in his lecture. He followed the order that Dr. Sovacool provided his idea. But there are some shortages in Kelvin’s summary. Firstly, he missed some advices on saving the climate change that Dr. Sovacool gave on his lecture. On the institution part, limiting the number of driving cars is missed. Advices about building and industry are also lost. On the individual part, eating locally grown food, purchasing used clothing and purchasing environmentally friendly or neutral items are missed. And he did not mention renewable electricity, energy efficiency and combined heat and power which can be supported by both institutions and individuals. In addition, there is a logical conflict in Kelvin’s summary. He wrote that “everyone may change his food habits or become a vegetarian.” For a non-vegetarian, becoming a vegetarian is definitely changing food habits. These are not two aspects, so ‘or’ is not proper here. I think he should use ‘even’, because becoming a vegetarian is a kind of changing food habits but it is one level up. Over all, Kelvin did a good job. He caught most of the main points in Dr. Sovacool’s lecture. But there are still a few aspects that he can improve on.

1 comment:

  1. I like your comment on the vegetarian point and the fact that you realised that there were two parts in the lecture - institution and individual which Kelvin somehow missed in his discussion.

    But your vocabulary must be more carefully selected: not "seldom" but "few" logical conflicts and not "shortages" in the summary but "missing points"!

    ReplyDelete